The H-index is a crucial measure of a researcher’s impact, reflecting both the quantity and influence of their published work. Its significance varies across academic positions, with expectations increasing from PhD students to senior faculty members. Strong H-index can enhance career opportunities, influence funding decisions, and establish credibility within a field. The ideal H-index for each stage of academia helps researchers set realistic goals and track their professional growth effectively.
Latest Read
| Academic Stage | Life Sciences | Physical Sciences | Engineering | Social Sciences | Humanities | Computer Science | Business & Economics |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PhD Student | 2-5 | 2-4 | 2-5 | 1-3 | 0-2 | 2-4 | 1-3 |
| Postdoc | 6-16 | 5-13 | 6-16 | 4-12 | 2-6 | 7-17 | 4-13 |
| Assistant Professor | 12-25 | 10-23 | 12-25 | 9-22 | 4-14 | 13-26 | 10-23 |
| Associate Professor | 20-40 | 18-38 | 20-40 | 17-35 | 10-26 | 21-40 | 18-36 |
| Full Professor | 32-60+ | 30-60+ | 32-60+ | 29-55+ | 20-40+ | 33-60+ | 30-56+ |
But what exactly constitutes a “good” h-index? And how does it vary across different academic positions and disciplines—from PhD students to position of tenured associate professor in fields as diverse as Life Sciences, Engineering, and Humanities?
Additional Information
Our comprehensive blog delves into the nuances of the h-index, its relevance in academic promotions, and the challenges it presents.
What is the h-index metric? What is a good h-index required for an academic position?
The h-index is a metric designed to quantify the productivity and impact of a researcher, and increasingly, groups or journals.
Developed by physicist Jorge Hirsch, this index is computed as the number of papers (number of publications) with citation numbers larger or equal to ‘h.’
The metric comes in handy when comparing scholars within the same field but has limitations when used across disciplines. This is due to factors such as the average number of references per paper, the typical productivity of researchers in the field, and the field’s overall size.
Several databases, like Google Scholar, Web of Science, and Scopus, offer h-index calculations. However, it’s crucial to note that your h-index may vary between platforms due to differences in their database’s scope and what papers they include.
The h-index has become a crucial factor in academia for promotions, with assistant professors often striving for a ‘good h-index’ to become a full professor.
The h-index is not without its challenges:
- it may not accurately reflect the impact of scholars with fewer but highly cited publications. In such cases, the h-index may paint an incomplete picture of an author’s impact, favoring those who publish more frequently regardless of the quality or impact of their work.
- it is heavily influenced by the field’s norms. For example, in disciplines where papers usually have fewer citations, even established researchers may have a relatively low h-index.
Despite its limitations, the h-index remains a widely-used metric for assessing the influence and productivity of researchers, offering a more nuanced picture than simply counting the number of papers published or the number of citations.
How to Calculate your h Index Score?
Calculating your h-index is a straightforward process, especially if you use academic databases that track citations. Here’s a simple step-by-step guide:
What is a Good h-index for a PhD Student?
Determining what constitutes a “good” h-index for a Ph.D. student can vary greatly depending on the academic field, the number of years the student has been in the program, and other factors like collaborative work and the prominence of the journals where they’ve published.
Here’s a table that attempts to provide some generalized benchmarks:
| Academic Field | Early-stage PhD (1-2 years) | Mid-stage PhD (2-4 years) | Late-stage PhD (4+ years) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Life Sciences | 2-3 | 3-5 | 5-7 | Publication norms and citation rates vary widely, so these are approximations. |
| Physical Sciences | 1-2 | 3-4 | 4-6 | Experimental work may take longer, thus affecting the h-index. |
| Engineering | 1-3 | 3-5 | 5-8 | Collaborative work, especially with professors, can significantly boost the h-index score and enhance research output. |
| Social Sciences | 1-2 | 2-4 | 3-5 | Books and book chapters may not be counted in traditional h-index calculations. |
| Humanities | 0-1 | 1-2 | 1-3 | Much work may be published in book form, affecting the h-index. |
| Computer Science | 2-4 | 4-6 | 6-9 | Frequent conference publications can boost the h-index. |
| Business & Economics | 1-2 | 2-4 | 3-5 | Varied types of publications, including case studies, can count. |
It’s worth noting that while a “good” h-index can be indicative of a productive and impactful research career, it’s not the only metric to consider. Quality of research, contribution to the field, and other factors like teaching and community service are also important.
What is a Good h-Index for a Postdoc?
“good” h-index for a Postdoc will typically be higher than for a PhD student, given the additional years of research and publications.
Again, the numbers can vary depending on the field, the productivity of the researcher, and other variables like the rate of collaboration and the types of journals in which they’ve published.
Here’s a generalized table:
| Academic Field | Early-stage Postdoc (1 year) | Mid-stage Postdoc (1-3 years) | Late-stage Postdoc (3+ years) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Life Sciences | 6-9 | 9-12 | 12-16 | Interdisciplinary work or high-impact journals can significantly influence these numbers. |
| Physical Sciences | 5-7 | 7-10 | 10-13 | Experimental work may take longer, thus affecting the h-index. |
| Engineering | 6-9 | 9-12 | 12-16 | A higher number of collaborative projects can boost these figures. |
| Social Sciences | 4-6 | 6-9 | 9-12 | Multi-author papers and impactful publications in high-ranking journals can contribute to a higher h-index. |
| Humanities | 2-4 | 3-5 | 4-6 | Books and long-form publications, not typically captured in h-index calculations, may slow these numbers. |
| Computer Science | 7-10 | 10-13 | 13-17 | High frequency of conference publications can lead to a higher h-index. |
| Business & Economics | 4-7 | 7-10 | 10-13 | A wide range of publication types including journal articles, conference papers, and case studies can influence the h-index. |
Remember that while the h-index is a useful metric, it’s not the end-all measure of academic success. Qualities like the impact and innovation of one’s research, mentorship, and broader contributions to science and the academic community are also vital aspects of a successful Postdoc experience.
What’s a Good h-index for an Assistant Professor Academic Position?
The h-index for an Assistant Professor would usually be higher than for a PhD student or Postdoc due to more years of research and publications.
Like in previous cases, the “good” h-index varies significantly based on academic field, years in the role, and other variables such as the type of institution, rate of collaboration, and types of journals in which the researcher has published.
Generalized table:
| Academic Field | Early-stage Assistant Professor (1-2 years) | Mid-stage Assistant Professor (2-5 years) | Late-stage Assistant Professor (5+ years) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Life Sciences | 12-16 | 16-20 | 20-25 | Publication in high-impact journals can significantly influence the h-index. |
| Physical Sciences | 10-14 | 14-18 | 18-23 | Long-term experimental work may take more time, potentially affecting the h-index. |
| Engineering | 12-16 | 16-20 | 20-25 | Collaborative work and applied research can contribute to a higher h-index. |
| Social Sciences | 9-13 | 13-17 | 17-22 | Diverse types of publications, including policy papers, can boost the h-index. |
| Humanities | 4-7 | 7-10 | 10-14 | Books and non-journal publications may not be captured in traditional h-index calculations. |
| Computer Science | 13-17 | 17-21 | 21-26 | Frequent conference publications can contribute to a higher h-index. |
| Business & Economics | 10-14 | 14-18 | 18-23 | A wide variety of publications, including case studies, can contribute to the h-index. |
What is a Good h-Index for an Associate Professor?
The h-index for an Associate Professor would typically be higher still, given the further years of research and publishing, as well as the likelihood of having guided PhD students and Postdocs, which often results in collaborative publications.
Here’s a generalized table:
| Academic Field | Early-stage Associate Professor (1-3 years) | Mid-stage Associate Professor (3-6 years) | Late-stage Associate Professor (6+ years) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Life Sciences | 20-26 | 26-32 | 32-40 | Leading large-scale research projects and publishing in high-impact journals can significantly influence the h-index. |
| Physical Sciences | 18-24 | 24-30 | 30-38 | Continued experimental work and high-quality publications are key to a higher h-index. |
| Engineering | 20-26 | 26-32 | 32-40 | Interdisciplinary and applied research, often cited in industry, can lead to a higher h-index. |
| Social Sciences | 17-23 | 23-29 | 29-35 | A broader influence, including policy papers and high-impact journals, can contribute. |
| Humanities | 10-16 | 16-20 | 20-26 | Books and other forms of long-form publications may not be counted in traditional h-index calculations. |
| Computer Science | 21-27 | 27-33 | 33-40 | Leading conferences and having high-impact papers can quickly raise the h-index. |
| Business & Economics | 18-24 | 24-30 | 30-36 | Journal publications, case studies, and policy influence can result in a higher h-index. |
H-index required for an academic position – Full professor?
Full Professor is generally expected to have a high h-index, reflecting a long career with significant contributions to research.
It’s important to recognize that the h-index will vary by academic field and will often be influenced by a range of factors such as international collaborations, research funding, and the impact factor of journals where the work is published.
Generalized table for what might be considered a “good” h-index for a Full Professor:
| Academic Field | Early-stage Full Professor (1-5 years) | Mid-stage Full Professor (5-10 years) | Late-stage Full Professor (10+ years) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Life Sciences | 32-40 | 40-50 | 50-60+ | Established researchers with significant grants and high-impact publications will likely have a higher h-index. |
| Physical Sciences | 30-38 | 38-48 | 48-60+ | Professors involved in long-term experimental projects and collaborations tend to have a higher h-index. |
| Engineering | 32-40 | 40-50 | 50-60+ | Those engaged in applied research with real-world applications often see higher citation rates, boosting their h-index. |
| Social Sciences | 29-35 | 35-45 | 45-55+ | Work that informs policy and public debates can significantly affect the h-index. |
| Humanities | 20-26 | 26-34 | 34-40+ | Humanities often rely on books and other forms of long-form publication, which are not always counted in traditional h-index calculations. |
| Computer Science | 33-40 | 40-50 | 50-60+ | Leading roles in influential conferences and research cited by the tech industry can contribute to a high h-index. |
| Business & Economics | 30-36 | 36-46 | 46-56+ | Impactful research that’s cited in both academic and industry publications can boost the h-index significantly. |
Wrapping up – What h-index is Considered Good?
The quest to quantify academic productivity and influence has led to the widespread adoption of the h-index as an evaluative metric.
FAQs
1. What is considered a good H-index?
A good H-index depends on the academic field and career stage. Generally, an H-index of 10–15 is strong for early-career researchers, 20–30 for mid-career academics, and 40+ for senior professors in research-intensive fields.
2. How does the H-index vary by academic position?
- PhD students: 3–5 (a promising start)
- Assistant Professors: 10–15 (growing research impact)
- Associate Professors: 15–25 (established research presence)
- Full Professors: 30+ (recognized authority in the field)
3. Does a higher H-index mean better research quality?
Not necessarily. While a higher H-index reflects citation impact, it does not always indicate the quality or significance of research. Some highly cited papers may be controversial rather than groundbreaking.
4. What is a good H-index for different fields?
H-index expectations differ across disciplines:
- STEM fields: Higher H-indices due to frequent citations (e.g., 30+ for senior academics).
- Social Sciences & Humanities: Lower averages (e.g., 10–20 for senior scholars).
5. How can researchers improve their H-index?
- Publish in high-impact journals.
- Collaborate with established researchers.
- Present at top conferences.
- Ensure research is accessible and well-promoted.
- Engage in open-access publishing for wider reach.
6. Does the H-index matter for academic promotions?
Yes, many universities and funding bodies consider the H-index when evaluating candidates for tenure, grants, and promotions. However, it is just one factor among other qualitative assessments.
7. Can the H-index be manipulated?
While self-citations and citation circles can artificially boost the H-index, unethical practices are discouraged and may damage credibility. Genuine impact is built through high-quality research and meaningful citations.
Best Read
